Board recruitment
“The Cabinet Office’s decision to disregard the Chair’s request to reappoint experienced non-executive directors significantly weakened the UKSA Board at a crucial time. It is the responsibility of the Cabinet Office to ensure an UKSA Board that is equipped to perform its role, not least by ensuring that it has a full complement of appointments and proper and timely succession planning to maintain capability as its membership evolves.” (Paragraph 76)
“It appears that the appointment of a new National Statistician will precede the appointment of a new permanent Chair of the UKSA. This means the appointment of the next National Statistician has been overseen by the interim Chair, and, while the role is split with the ONS Permanent Secretary, will have to ensure clear responsibilities and lines of accountability for both. That the Government has left responsibility for this in the hands of an interim appointment is regrettable. A permanent chair of the UKSA should be appointed as soon as possible.” (Paragraph 81)
Decisions about appointing members of the Authority Board are for Ministers to take, as set out in sections 3 and 4 of the Statistics and Registration Service Act 2007. Like any effective board, the Authority Board requires a balance of experience in areas including leadership, technology, governance, and audit. It also requires specialist knowledge relevant to official statistics. Much of the value that individual members bring is built through sustained engagement with the Authority, ONS and the wider statistical system. New members bring valuable experience and challenge but will not immediately replace the knowledge and expertise lost when several experienced members leave within a short period. Timely succession planning is therefore essential to maintain the effectiveness of the Board. Competitions should be initiated well in advance of known departure dates to allow appointments to be completed and, where appropriate, an orderly handover to take place.
The Authority agrees with the Committee that the Board has been hampered by delays in appointments and by decisions neither to reappoint existing members nor to maintain momentum on their timely replacement. Appointments to the Authority Board have repeatedly taken too long over a period of several years, despite the end dates of members’ terms being known well in advance and repeated representations from the Authority about the need to begin recruitment in good time.
Experience over recent years suggests that while ministerial changes add additional delays, the Cabinet Office has not consistently had sufficient capacity to ensure key public appointments are made within the necessary timescales. The Authority is discussing with the Cabinet Office sponsorship team how the arrangements can be improved. The Authority would be willing to provide greater administrative support for future competitions, as it has done previously, where this would help them proceed in a timely way, while respecting the decision-making role ultimately reserved for Ministers.
The Authority welcomes the competitions for a permanent Chair and three new non-executive members, which began in October, and hope these will be completed in a timely fashion.
The Authority would welcome the Committee continuing to take a close interest in the administration of future appointments. The Authority will keep the Committee informed of progress on current competitions, the appointment of a permanent Chair and its discussions with the Cabinet Office about more sustainable arrangements for future appointments.